← All playbooks

Offers & Decisions

How to Compare College Offers

Compare offers on what the next four years would actually look like: real cost after all aid, your likely role, the degree you want, and whether you'd be happy there without the sport. The biggest number isn't always the best offer.

Published October 29, 2026

The number isn't the whole offer

It's easy to line up offers by the scholarship amount and pick the biggest. But a large athletic award at an expensive school can cost more than a smaller one somewhere else, and the money only matters if you're happy there.

Compare the real cost

• Total cost of attendance, not just tuition.
• Athletic aid plus academic and need-based aid.
• What's guaranteed, and for how long.
• What the family actually pays each year.

Compare your role

• How many players at your position, and their grad years?
• Where does the coach see you in year one and year two?
• How long has the coach been there, and are they likely to stay?

Compare the life

• Do they have the major you want?
• Size, location, distance from home.
• How current players describe the team and the coach.

Would you still choose this school if you never played a game? That answer breaks most ties.

Instead of

"School A is giving me more money, so that's the one."

Say this

"School A covers more, but School B has my major and a clearer path to play. Let's look at what each one costs us each year."

The move

Make a simple side-by-side for your top two: real yearly cost, your likely role, your major, and how it felt on campus. Talk it through as a family before you decide.

Stop guessing who's paying attention.

Answer 4 quick questions and get one clear step your family can take this week. No score, no grade.

Prospect-Orbit Pro syncs your coach emails automatically, keeps every program's status in one view, and reminds you when it's time to follow up.